Category Archives: Personalized Medicine

Subscribe to Personalized Medicine RSS Feed

Proving Utility, Demonstrating Value: How to Align the Moving Parts in Personalized Medicine Reimbursement

HC-Reiumbursement
Of the many business, operational, legal, regulatory and clinical obstacles standing in the way of widespread delivery of personalized medicine, the single greatest challenge may lie in solving the reimbursement puzzle. Advocates of personalized medicine contend that it results in better care for the patient, as therapy is targeted specific to an individual, and that … Continue reading this entry

Forget Bigger Data – Personalized Medicine Needs Smarter Data to Reach its Full Potential

Shot of male pharmacist sitting at his desk and working with digital tablet and computer
The advent of big data has helped enable the growth of personalized medicine. But if machine learning and analytics are to truly help transform health care, it won’t be through bigger data, but through harmonized, smarter data.… Continue reading this entry

Seven Key Questions in Understanding the Current Regulatory State of HCT/Ps

microscope
Despite regulations, litigation, and significant draft guidance, the future of regulation of HCT/Ps remains up in the air.  Learn what you need to know quickly with these seven questions and answers. What do I Need to Know?… Continue reading this entry

HHS and Medicare Asked to Expand Coverage for Genetic Tests

header-1
Fifteen members of Congress have asked the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) and the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (Medicare) to examine how the federal government can help improve patient access to genetic testing. In a March 7, 2017 letter to Secretary Price of HHS and Dr. Crosson, Chairman of Medicare, the congressmen seek a … Continue reading this entry

One is Not Enough – Infringement Liability under § 271(f)(1)

Infringement-Abstract_Dark
In Life Technologies Corp. v. Promega Corp., Slip Op. 14-1538 (Feb. 22, 2017), the U.S. Supreme Court held that the supply of a single component of a multicomponent invention for manufacture abroad does not give rise to liability under 35 U.S.C. § 271(f)(1). The Court’s decision is important for manufacturers of kit components and those that … Continue reading this entry

FEDERAL CIRCUIT KNOCKS OUT PATENTS AFTER CBM CHALLENGE

helix1
Guest Post by Jocelyn Yu, Foley & Lardner, LLP. Apple successfully invalidated three patents for failure to recite patent eligible subject matter. Apple, Inc. v. Ameranth, Inc., 2015-1792, 2015-1793 (Fed. Cir. 2016). The patents relate to synchronous communication systems for electronically generating and transmitting menu selections. While the covered technology is not directly related to … Continue reading this entry

Precision Medicine - Obama’s Health Care Legacy

federal_eagle1
As we come to the end of President Obama’s administration, it is time to look back on the past eight years and the administration’s impact on the delivery of the nation’s health care. While the Affordable Care Act (signed into law early in the President’s administration on March 23rd, 2010) is a significant achievement in … Continue reading this entry

New Report Outlines 5 Year Plan to Achieve Cancer Moonshot

federal_eagle1
The Cancer Moonshot Task Force has just released its 5 year plan for implementing President Obama’s “Cancer Moonshot” program (“Report”). The initiative, announced during President Obama’s 2016 State of the Union Address, is a national effort to dramatically accelerate efforts to prevent, diagnose and treat cancer that take advantage of recent advances in molecular medicine … Continue reading this entry

Personalized Medicine: Insights Into Current Legal Issues

PersonalizedMedicine-Abstract-Light
Guest Post by:  Nate Beaver, Esq.; Gary Koch, Esq.; Antoinette Konski, Esq.; and Judy Waltz, Esq., Foley & Lardner, LLP. In his January 20, 2015 State of the Union address, President Obama brought to the nation’s attention the promise of personalized medicine when he announced the Precision Medicine Initiative (the “PMI”). In announcing this initiative during … Continue reading this entry

Ariosa Loses Verinata Patent Challenge

cell
Fetal diagnostic pioneer Ariosa Diagnostics lost its latest attempt to invalidate competitor Verinata Health’s U.S. Patent No. 8,318,430, “Methods of Fetal Abnormality Detection.” The USPTO’s Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) concluded that Petitioner Ariosa Diagnostics (Ariosa) failed to demonstrate the unpatentability of challenged claims 1-30. Ariosa Diagnostics, Inc. v. Verinata Health, Inc., IPR2013-0027/-00277 (PTAB … Continue reading this entry

Advancing Personalized Medicine Through Cross-sector Collaboration and Innovation

16.11832_BPM_blog-ad
Since 2013, thought leaders, innovators, and health care specialists have convened for a one day summit to discuss the business of personalized medicine. The Business of Personalized Medicine Summit, explores the economic, legal and regulatory barriers to making personalized medicine a reality for patients everywhere while sharing strategies for success. This year’s Summit – Strategies for Partnering … Continue reading this entry

FDA Issues Guidance on Use of Public Human Genetic Variant Databases and Their Use in Personalized Medicine

fda
Next Generation Sequencing (NGS) permits the analysis of millions of genetic variants at a time and has proven to be invaluable for the development of personalized or precision medicine. Analysis of whole genomes is providing insight into the diagnosis, prediction and treatment of disease, and will continue to do so as more genetic information is collected and … Continue reading this entry

FDA Issues Draft Guidance To Streamline Regulatory Oversight Of NGS-Based Tests For Diagnosing Germline Diseases

untitled
Personalized or Precision Medicine needs reliable and accurate diagnostic tests to guide clinical intervention and treatment decisions. Traditional testing of germline variants is site-specific and therefore only provides information on one or at most, several variants at a time. Advances in DNA sequencing technology, notably Next Generation Sequencing (NGS), permit the analysis of millions of variants … Continue reading this entry

FEDERAL CIRCUIT’S RECENT PRIMER ON PATENT-ELIGIBILITY

PatentEligibility-Abstract-Light
A method of producing a desired population of multi-cryopreserved hepatocytes was held to be patent-eligible because the challenged claims did not recite a judicial exception. Rapid Litig. v. CellzDirect, Inc.., 2015-1570 (Fed. Cir., July 5th 2016). The decision provides much needed guidance to the life science industry that had yet to receive positive guidance from … Continue reading this entry

Will the Supreme Court Clarify Patent-Eligibility?

The United States Supreme Court is set to render its decision on the grant or denial of Sequenom, Inc.’s (“Sequenom’s”) petition for writ of certiorari that posed the issue: Whether a novel method is patent-eligible where: (1) a researcher is the first to discover a natural phenomenon; (2) that unique knowledge motivates him to apply … Continue reading this entry

EMA’s New Draft Guideline On Good Pharmacogenomic Practice - Implications For Personalized Medicine

testtube
Embracing personalized medicine, the European Medicines Agency (EMA) released a draft guidance document titled Draft Guideline on Good Pharmacogenomic Practice (“Guidance”) on good pharmacogenomic practice with the stated goal of developing and laying out appropriate genomic methodologies for use during the development and life-cycle of a drug. Past issues and problems that have been encountered … Continue reading this entry

USPTO RELEASES PATENT ELIGIBILITY UPDATE

PatentEligibility
On May 4, 2016, the USPTO released a “May 2016 Subject Matter Eligibility Update” (“Update”) providing guidance to patent examiners on formulating a subject matter eligibility rejection and evaluating an applicant’s response to that rejection. The USPTO concurrently released new life science examples to assist examiners and applicants evaluate whether claimed discoveries satisfy 35 U.S.C. … Continue reading this entry

Capitalizing on Collaboration – The President’s Precision Medicine Initiative

federal_eagle1
Last week President Obama marked the one year anniversary of his Precision Medicine Initiative (“PMI”) by holding a web-accessible panel discussion where he and interested stakeholders discussed his PMI initiative, its progress and future direction. The President also announced a series of awards, funded by the National Institutes of Health (“NIH”), to build the infrastructure … Continue reading this entry

Data Transmission, Personalized Medicine, and Privacy

healthcare_IT
Health care analytics make use of patient data to inform treatment decisions and is increasingly moving front and center in personalized medicine. For example, the President’s Precision Medicine Initiative (see post of January 26, 2016) has rolled out a program to collect health data from one million volunteers to inform and guide future research. Consumers … Continue reading this entry

The President’s Precision Medicine Initiative – The First Annual Check-Up

PersonalizedMedicine
Watching President Obama’s recent 2016 State of the Union Address reminded me that one year has passed since the President announced a new “precision” or personalized medicine initiative to advance personalized, effective therapies for the American public. It was during his 2015 State of the Union Address that the President stated:[1] “[T]onight, I’m launching a … Continue reading this entry

FDA Oversight of Diagnostic Medicine – A Trap for the Unwary

2015BPMS-blog-ad
Diagnostic medicine is experiencing new challenges at the USPTO and the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA). Under a new FDA proposal, laboratory developed test providers, previously exempt from FDA oversight, must now consider if their diagnostic test may be subject to FDA oversight, either as a moderate risk (Class II) or high-risk (Class III) … Continue reading this entry

Patent Subject Matter Eligibility – Impact on Litigation and Prosecution

DiagnosticMethods-Icons-Dark
Personalized medicine relies on diagnostic technologies to accurately evaluate a patient’s clinical or genetic signature to guide treatment decisions. Protecting innovation by patenting the diagnostic methods and tools that inform clinical intervention and treatment has been the traditional means to protect investment in these important technologies. Recent U.S. Supreme Court decisions have challenged inventors’ ability … Continue reading this entry

Breaking Through to Business Solutions for Personalized Medicine: A Thought-Provoking, Can’t-Miss Industry Event

BPMS_Blog2
Just as with patient treatments, one size does not fit all when it comes to companies involved in personalized medicine. Each is unique in its mission, culture, and capabilities, so it should come as no surprise that each demands a distinct business strategy that can evolve alongside the industry. The annual Business of Personalized Medicine … Continue reading this entry

Protecting Diagnostic Innovation – Two Actor Infringement Liability

stemcell
In Akamai Techs. Inc. v. Limelight Networks, Inc., (August 13, 2015 Fed. Cir.) an en banc Federal Circuit unanimously held that direct infringement under Section 271(a) can occur: ”where all steps of a claimed method are performed by or attributed to a single entity…Where more than one actor is involved in practicing the steps, a … Continue reading this entry